All-Capital Athletic Conference
1991 (2)
- James Rebholz (1st team)
- Mark Zettle (1st team)
1992 (4)
- Darren Hawkins (1st team)
- James Rebholz (1st team)
- Corey Cooke (1st team)
- Robert Kirk (2nd team)
1993 (3)
- Darren Hawkins (1st team)
- John McManus (1st team)
- Jeff Sack (2nd team)
1994 (3)
- Darren Hawkins (1st team)
- Jeff Sack (1st team)
- John McManus (2nd team)
1995 (2)
- John McManus (1st team)
- Jeff Sack (1st team)
1997 (3)
- John O'Connor (1st team)
- Matt Tenney (1st team)
- David Adams (2nd team)
1998 (2)
- Ryan Olsen (1st team)
- Matt Tenney (2nd team)
1999 (1)
- Ryan Olsen (1st team)
2000 (3)
- Ryan Olsen (1st team)
- Alun Oliver (2nd team)
- Jamison Combs (2nd team)
2001 (3)
- Ryan Olsen (1st team)
- Alun Oliver (2nd team)
- Micah Spiegel (2nd team)
2002 (2)
- Alun Oliver (1st team)
- Brian Wolcott (1st team)
2003 (3)
- Ever Dinarte (1st team)
- Alun Oliver (1st team)
- Brian Wolcott (1st team)
2004 (2)
- Brian Wolcott (1st team)
- Joe Valentino (2nd team)
2005 (2)
- Nathaniel Graham (2nd team)
- Alex Pyzik (2nd team)
2006 (2)
- David Reumont (1st team)
- Sean Eardley (2nd team)
2007 (4)
- Mike Rohrs (1st team)
- Mikael Tigrett (1st team)
- Tim Guinan (2nd team)
- Alex Pyzik (2nd team)
2008 (4)
- Benard Agyingi (2nd team)
- Cyrus Albertson (2nd team)
- Chris Madrigal (2nd team)
- Chris Quamina (2nd team)
2009 (2)
- Brian Payne (2nd team)
- Ted Scharfenberg (2nd team)
2010 (2)
- Brian Payne (1st team)
- Kevin Seeger (2nd team)

